“Opening the Black Box” is our ongoing series on the data treatments, assumptions, and methodologies behind our analyses. In this series, we answer frequently asked questions on how we build, validate, and make decisions about our data.
Thoughts or feedback for us? We welcome it.
In our last post, we looked at how CEM accounts for leverage to ensure peer comparisons are apples-to-apples. Currency is another factor that can distort comparisons if not handled carefully.
Here, we share how CEM converts data across currencies, and how hedging should be reported so that your fund’s results reflect your fund’s investment decisions, not exchange rate movements.
Converting holdings and costs across currencies
In any given year, CEM receives investment data in more than 15 different currencies. To make these comparable, all holdings and costs are converted to the subscriber’s local currency using year-end Purchasing Power Parity (PPP) exchange rates sourced from leading third-party providers of market data.
The PPP exchange rates are designed to account for differences in what a currency can buy in its home economy. This gives a more meaningful basis for comparing economic quantities, such as investment costs, across geographies.
Converting returns
Returns are converted using spot exchange rates to reflect the impact of currency movements on the investment performance over the reporting period. The approach is further refined by the composition of the peer group.
For returns, we have two different approaches: one for exclusively domestic peer groups and a second for geographically diverse peer groups.
For domestic peer groups, such as U.S.-only peer groups or UK-only peer groups, returns are shown converted to the subscriber’s currency using year-end spot exchange rates.
For geographically diverse peer groups, which are common amongst our most sophisticated subscribers, returns are shown unconverted. This reduces the noise that currency movements would otherwise add to the return comparisons. Subscribers can request returns on a converted basis.
Reporting currency hedging
The impact of currency hedging on your fund’s benchmarking results depends on the level at which the hedging occurs (e.g., total fund or asset class).
If your fund hedges currency at the total fund level, CEM asks you to report it as an overlay, along with its cost. The cost of the hedging program includes the internal team’s cost or, if externally managed, the fees to the external manager. The gains and losses should be reported on a net basis as part of the overlay.
In this example, the net returns and benchmark returns should be reported unhedged so that the total fund returns reflect performance of the assets, agnostic of the currency movements.
Alternatively, if your fund hedges at the asset class level, asset class returns and benchmarks should be reported on a hedged basis.
Net value added, which is the difference between net returns and benchmark returns, takes most of the currency noise out of cross-geography comparisons, as long as the return and the benchmark are measured the same way, i.e., both hedged or both unhedged. The principle in both cases is the same. Returns and their benchmarks must be measured on a consistent currency basis. This ensures that the difference between your return and your benchmark reflects your actual investment decisions, not differences in currency movements.
The challenge with discretionary hedging
Discretionary hedging, where managers have the freedom to deviate from hedging targets, makes this harder. Because returns end up with varying degrees of hedging, it becomes difficult to choose the right benchmark, for example, a fully hedged index versus partial hedging. This can create a disconnect between your total fund return and your policy return. While this is not addressed in our standard benchmarking, our Research & Analytics team can more deeply explore it with you, on request.
Hedging in our risk model
CEM also accounts for hedging in our risk model. We ask for the proportion of your US and non-US assets that are hedged, and use hedged indices in the same proportion to model the risk of your policy allocation. CEM calculates the risk of policy mix for all participants to allow you to make comparisons on a standardized basis.
We will cover more detail on how CEM benchmarks performance in a later blog.
Our committment to you
The trust our subscribers have placed in us over the years, many for close to a decade without interruption, is something we take seriously. This series is one way of honouring that trust. We are not here to simply explain ourselves. We are here to open a dialogue that pushes our work, and the industry, forward.
We look forward to hearing from you. If there is a question you would like us to address, please reach out to us at insights@explorecem.com.
This blog is part of our “Opening the Black Box” series. If you’d like to receive new posts in your inbox, please click here to subscribe.