How does CEM address incomplete or incomparable fees? 

“Opening the Black Box” is our ongoing series on the data treatments, assumptions, and methodologies behind our analyses. In this series, we answer frequently asked questions on how we build, validate, and make decisions about our data.   

Thoughts or feedback for us?  We welcome it.  

In our last post, we looked at how CEM accounts for differences in currency and hedging so that your fund’s results reflect your investment decisions, not exchange rate movements. This post turns to costs. Specifically, what happens when the fees reported to us are incomplete, or are not reported on the same basis as peers. 

Here, we share when and how CEM applies imputations, how imputed fees are treated in your benchmarking results, and how incomparable fees are handled. 

Why consistency matters

Benchmarking investment costs requires a consistent definition of cost and a formal review that all reported amounts are complete and reported on the same basis. Without this consistency, comparisons between peers can be flawed. 

We have seen this firsthand. When we reviewed the cost disclosures in Form 5500 in the U.S., which U.S. Defined Contribution plans are required to file, we found discrepancies and inconsistencies in cost reporting across plans. Unvetted and inconsistent data can lead to vastly different benchmarking results. You can read the findings here.

Through CEM’s data cleaning and validation process, we ensure that fees are reported consistently. 

When fees are incomplete or incomparable

When reported fees are incomplete or incomparable, and the subscriber is not able to clarify them, CEM applies standardized, database-driven imputations to make costs comparable across funds. Imputations are always clearly identified in CEM reports. The imputation methodology and application process is overseen by CEM’s Data Governance Committee. 

The imputations reflect the typical fees paid by a representative group of funds over the relevant time frame. For example, fee imputation for private equity limited partnerships is calculated based on a combination of deal terms in private equity contracts that are optionally reported to CEM on the LP survey, the last two years of management fee data in the database, and the trend in the last five years of management fees. 

Fees that are known to be zero vs. fees that are unknown

An important distinction is between fees that are known to be zero and fees that are simply unknown. 

If a fund does not pay performance fees on public equity mandates, these fees are recorded as zero. However, if carried interest is not reported for private market funds, it is treated as unknown rather than zero. In this case, an imputed value is applied based on the experience of other funds in the database in the same year. 

For transparency, all imputed values are clearly identified in the reporting appendices. 

How imputed fees affect your benchmarking results

Imputed fees are included in a fund’s total investment costs, but are excluded from benchmarking. The example below illustrates the rationale. 

Fund of funds is a common case. Some subscribers do not have full look-through into underlying base fees for fund of funds. CEM imputes underlying fund of funds fees to reflect the true cost of fund of funds. Not imputing these fees would understate the true cost of investing in fund of funds relative to direct funds. 

However, these imputed fees are not benchmarked. In other words, they do not impact your relative position against the benchmark. This is done by setting the benchmark cost for imputed cost line items equal to the value of the imputation, with the assumption that the median peer pays a fee rate equal to the imputation. This means funds are neither penalized nor rewarded relative to their peers for imputed costs.   

The imputed costs are still considered part of the fund’s total costs when comparing the absolute costs of programs in order to reflect the true cost of running these programs. 

When reported fees are not on the same basis as peers

In some cases, even though fees are reported, they can be incomparable to peers if they are not reported on the same basis. Management base fees for private market closed-ended funds are a common area where we see incomparable fees. 

General Partners (GPs) often retain certain revenues that are offset against management fees. As a result, management fees are frequently reported net of these offsets.

For consistent benchmarking, CEM requests gross management fees. These can be obtained directly from partnership statements or estimated from the deal terms in the Limited Partnership Agreement (LPA). 

We recommend that subscribers fill out CEM’s optional LP survey. If the deal terms are provided, CEM can calculate the implied gross management fee based on the individual contracts. Subscribers also receive a complimentary report on limited partnerships. 

Raising the bar on cost transparency

Ideally, CEM would like to capture all costs that are netted from returns, such as partnership expenses and transaction costs, to provide fuller context to performance net of fees. However, regulatory requirements on cost disclosures vary across regions. 

For instance, Dutch funds have stringent disclosure requirements and even disclose transaction costs. In other regions, however, few funds have sufficient information on hand, particularly around the GP’s share of revenues, due to the opaque nature of private investments. For most funds, these costs can be difficult to identify, sometimes requiring information beyond partnership financial statements, and cannot be consistently validated across all peers. 

CEM’s ultimate objective is to continue to push the industry toward better and more transparent reporting, and over time to raise the bar to include costs in addition to investment management in the benchmarking. Read more about CEM’s Global Reporting Principles to learn about our initiative for better reporting.  

Our committment to you

The trust our subscribers have placed in us over the years, many for close to a decade without interruption, is something we take seriously. This series is one way of honouring that trust. We are not here to simply explain ourselves. We are here to open a dialogue that pushes our work, and the industry, forward. 

We look forward to hearing from you. If there is a question you would like us to address, please reach out to us at insights@explorecem.com. 

This blog is part of our “Opening the Black Box” series. If you’d like to receive new posts in your inbox, please click here to subscribe.  

Insights

More Related Articles

LGPS investment costs: reported, but not reliable

How does CEM account for differences in currency and hedging?

Beyond the Premium: A Better Way to Benchmark Private Credit